Comparison of dilution factors for German wastewater treatment plant effluents in receiving streams to the fixed dilution factor from chemical risk assessment
2017
Abstract Incomplete removal during wastewater treatment leads to frequent detection of compounds such as pharmaceuticals and personal care products in municipal effluents. A fixed standard
dilutionfactor of 10 for effluents entering receiving water bodies is used during the
exposure assessmentof several chemical risk assessments. However, the
dilutionpotential of German receiving waters under low
flow conditionsis largely unknown and information is sparse for other European countries. We calculated
dilutionfactors for two datasets differing in spatial extent and wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) size: a national dataset comprising 1225 large WWTPs in Central and Northern Germany and a federal dataset for 678 WWTPs of a single state in Southwest Germany. We found that the fixed factor approach overestimates the
dilutionpotential of 60% and 40% of receiving waters in the national and the federal dataset, with median
dilutionfactors of 5 and 14.5, respectively. Under mean
flow conditions, 8% of calculated
dilutionfactors were below 10, with a median
dilutionfactor of 106. We also calculated regional
dilutionfactors that accounted for effluent inputs from upstream WWTPs. For the national and the federal dataset, 70% and 60% of calculated regional
dilutionfactors fell below 10 under mean low
flow conditions, respectively. Decrease of regional
dilutionpotential in small receiving streams was mainly driven by the next WWTP upstream with a 2.5 fold drop of median regional
dilutionfactors. Our results show that using the standard
dilutionfactor of 10 would result in the underestimation of environmental concentrations for authorised chemicals by a factor of 3–5 for about 10% of WWTPs, especially during low
flow conditions. Consequently, measured environmental concentrations might exceed predicted environmental concentrations and ecological risks posed by effluents could be much higher, suggesting that a revision of current risk assessment practices may be required.
Keywords:
-
Correction
-
Source
-
Cite
-
Save
-
Machine Reading By IdeaReader
40
References
23
Citations
NaN
KQI